I’m Enjoying Creepy Things

Back in the summer, I read The Death of Mrs. Westaway by Ruth Ware. Hal, the main character, rents a boardwalk booth as a tarot card reader, like her mother did before her. Tarot features pretty heavily in the plot, even as Hal herself acknowledges that’s it’s more a tool up for interpretation than a fortune-telling device. I never would have thought to learn about tarot on my own, but it was really enjoyable for me to learn some of the basics through this book. I pass a tarot card reader on my way home from work every day, and I’ve always jokingly threathened to go in and get a tarot reading. If I’m ever on vacation or something and get the opportunity, I would try it for fun.

Right around Halloween this year, I listened to this episode of the NYT’s podcast The Argument. The podcast is mostly political, but in this epidsode the hosts interviewed author Tara Isabella Burton to discuss spirituality in America. Apparently, even though membership in organized religion here is declining, spirituality isn’t. More and more people, especially millennials, are turning to astrology, witchcraft, and other forms of the occult to satisfy their religious and spiritual needs. I found this really interesting on the heels of reading Mrs. Westaway. I’ve always said I don’t believe in ghosts or anything like that, and I don’t really, but I find it hugely enjoyable to read about people who do and other similar beliefs they have. (I celebrated Halloween by spending way too long reading the comments on this post by Ask a Manager of people telling their work-related ghost stories.)

Through November I’ve been unintentionally following this kind of occult thread. When I was in middle school, I was in a girls’ book club. We would take turns picking books to read, and one month someone picked Coraline. This book absolutely terrified me. For weeks after reading it I was petrified being the dark alone because I was afraid the Other Mother’s severed hand would come after me like it came after Coraline. I’ve always remembered that book, and so this year I finally watched the movie adaptation, both to face my childhood fear and also kind of hoping to be scared that way again. I actually found the movie really charming and sweet, but I don’t remember enough details from the book to remember what they may have cut. I might have to reread the book. Regardless, I enjoyed it.

I don’t remember what exactly led me to Shirley Jackson, but I discovered her shortly after watching Coraline. Just this weekend, I’ve consumed We Have Always Lived in the Castle, “The Lottery,” “The Man in the Woods,” and “Paranoia.” I have mixed feelings on all of these. “Paranoia” was my favorite, about a man who thinks he’s being followed on his way home from work. “The Lottery” was straightforward and chilling, but because it didn’t explain why the lottery worked the way it did, or even allude to a reason, I didn’t love this one. (Sinister motives and twisted rationales intrigue me more than people just doing strange things for unexplained reasons.) We Have Always Lived in the Castle underwhelmed me at first but is growing on me the more I think about it (why, Merricat? Poor Constance!). And finally, other reviewers on Goodreads have said that “The Man in the Woods” lacks enough details to be really creepy, and I tend to agree (although the subplot about the cats was great).

Oh yes, the cats! I love them, in case you haven’t noticed, and the fact that they feature in many of the creepy things I’ve read recently is so fun. Jonas the cat is almost a main character in We Have Always Lived in the Castle, and his presence lends an even creepier vibe to Merricat’s narrative. (Part of me wants to read it again and write an essay on the importance of Jonas to the story.) A cat gets replaced by another in “The Man in the Woods,” maybe as a foil or foreshadowing to the titular man. And in Coraline, the cat is the only creature that can travel back and forth between the two worlds safely. He plays a big role in helping Coraline escape.

I’ve really enjoyed reading and watching creepy things lately. I don’t enjoy overt horror or gore (see The Bunker Diary or Stephen King), but give me all the psychological, weird, or ghostly stories right now. I’m finally dipping my toe into some new genres – we’ll see if it sticks!

Here’s a final random recommendation I’m too lazy to fit in anywhere else in this post but can’t not include: Skelehime, a horror cartoonist. She posts comics on Twitter (and a few on Instagram I think) and on her website. I enjoyed “Stanley Needs a Nest” and “The Sacker Street Ghost.”

What do you think of horror and the occult (in lit or as spirituality)? Can anyone recommend more books or short stories along these lines? Has anyone read Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House or watched the Netflix adaptation?

Photo by Ján Jakub Naništa on Unsplash


  1. I can remember reading “Carrie” by Stephen King when I was a young teenager. It scared the Bejeesus out of me! I thought telekinesis would be cool, so I tried a few times, but never was able to levitate anything. Now, I think all the occult stuff is just people telling “ghost stories” to scare themselves and each other.

  2. I love mystery, thriller, and horror, so I feel like this post is my time to shine!? Haha. I really enjoyed We Have Always Lived in the Castle – it felt so dark and twisted – and “The Lottery” was pretty good as well. The Haunting of Hill House as a book didn’t impress me all that much, but I adore the Netflix series, maybe because it has little to nothing in common with the book. Coraline is one of my favorite books – I read it well into my teens, and I’ve always wondered how it may have affected me as a kid (to be honest, I probably would have adored it then as well, I’ve always loved dark things.)

    If you’re looking for gothic novels I highly recommend Daphne du Maurier – Rebecca, My Cousin Rachel, and The Birds and Other Stories are three excellent books by her. Simone St. James is another one of my favorites – she writes paranormal historical fiction (ghosts, mostly) and her latest (and best so far) was a contemporary paranormal thriller, titled The Broken Girls. I *loved* The Death of Mrs. Westaway, by the way, and based on that Riley Sager could be an author you’d enjoy. His thrillers always keep me on the edge of my seat – my favorite by him is The Last Time I Lied, but his two other books are also A+. That’s all I could think of off the top of my head. 🙂 Great post!

  3. I just struggled horribly with American Gods (another book by Neil Gaiman) and I bailed out halfway through. I’m not sure I’d ever give him another chance even though Coraline seems up my alley. I’m a fair fan of Stephen King, and many (most?) of his books don’t strike me as gross-out horror. I’d recommend Hearts in Atlantis as a slightly creepy, engaging story (really four interconnected novelettes).

Got thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.